Alright, I don't usually have a post just dedicated to linking to a comment or a comment thread. But I'm going to make an exception here.
I recently followed a link over to a post by Marc Shapiro over at the Seforim blog. We all know that Marc Shapiro's stuff is generally great, that's not a chiddush. Check out the comments at the post by one Mendy, particularly regarding the Kuzari Principle. That's where the pwnage is at.
[No comments for this post since it would be more productive to go over there. If you wanna argue, argue with Mendy. If you wanna say, "epic pwnage!", say it to Mendy.]